How to Structure Your Rental Catalog for Better Conversions? Variants or Separate Listings?

Structuring Your Rental Catalog: Variants vs. Separate Listings

One of the most common questions in setting up a rental online store is how to structure the product catalog. Should different versions of a product be grouped under one listing as variants, or should they stand alone? The answer often depends on your customer acquisition strategy and the specific nature of your inventory.

When to Use Variants

Sizing: In most rental scenarios, sizing (e.g., S, M, L bike frames) does not affect the rental price. The industry standard is to treat these as variants within a single listing. This keeps your category pages clean and prevents customers from having to scroll through identical photos just to find their size.

Upsells and Tiers: When dealing with "Standard" versus "Pro" models, you have a choice. If you want to use the "Pro" model as an upsell, keeping it as a variant with a price modifier allows the customer to upgrade seamlessly on the product page.

When to Use Separate Listings

If your marketing strategy involves driving traffic to a general collection page, having separate listings for high-value items can make your inventory appear more robust and allows you to highlight specific features of premium models that might get lost in a dropdown menu.

The TWICE Commerce 2.0 Advantage

TWICE Commerce 2.0 allows for a unique approach to this dilemma through the separation of listings and inventory. With TWICE 2.0, you can:

  • Point multiple different listings to the same pool of serialized inventory.
  • A/B test your storefront by creating one listing with variants and several separate listings simultaneously.
  • Optimize your flow based on whether traffic is landing on your home page or a specific product landing page.

This flexibility ensures that your operational inventory management remains accurate while you experiment with the best customer-facing presentation.

Tuomo: When does something become a variant and when is it just a separate listing That's actually in many cases, it's a preference by the merchant and it's a preference like how do you believe that your customers end up finding the end solution the best way? So sizes often I think the standard tends to be that as it doesn't necessarily have a price implication to it, you might use that as a variant instead of creating separate listings for all of the size of bikes you have.

Things like additional sales or like a pro model versus standard model, those start to be maybe things that it can be either or and both can be actually true at the same time. So I might have separate listings or then inside a listing I might want to make it a selection for the user and then in that case you probably want to have that price increase for the pro model compared to the standard model.

Karri: Something that comes to my mind is like the productization or the flow, how you are actually sending the customer to your twice online store. So if you have some product page that you are actually driving traffic, you might want to show a lot of options there, but then on the other hand you might direct them to your let's say home page of your online store where they can see the whole inventory or some collection category page.

As you mentioned in twice, both can actually be true. So the really nice thing about the twice 2.0 is the complete separation of listings and inventory and you can have multiple listings pointing to the same inventory articles and kind of test out if you want to have one listing with a lot of different variants or separate listings and still utilize the same inventory.